If reports are to believed, talks are taking place that would mean the women's
Six Nations next year would be split into a two tier competition, seeing
England, France and Ireland in 'Tier 1', with Wales along with Scotland and
Italy in 'Tier 2'.
The teams in Tier 1 would compete in a Tri-Nations type format playing each other home and away, while the Tier 2 sides would play just two games and alternate home and away every other year.
This would be a bitter pill to swallow for the women's game, and would leave
Wales playing just two competitive matches in a World Cup year - hardly the
ideal preparation!
With women's rugby arguably getting more recognition and media coverage than ever, what is the motivation behind such a move? As with most things in this world, it looks like this move is coming down to money and the fact that the governing bodies involved with the sides that would move down to Tier 2 would like to reduce the associated costs and travel expenses.
Wales, who secured fourth place in the Six Nations and guaranteeing their spot in next year's World Cup as a result, came within minutes of beating eventual grand slam champions Ireland and also came similarly close to beating England.
That said, then, a lot of chatter has revolved around whether the Welsh
Rugby Union are behind or backing the said proposals? Obviously with no
official word from rugby's governing body in Wales at this point, it is all
still very much speculation.
In recent years, the structure of the women's game in Wales has been improved having seen a regional competition introduced, meaning the top players can compete at a higher level. Admittedly, the problem of league clubs folding due to lack of players is a very real problem, but the growth of new clubs like Penallta shows just what can be achieved when clubs support their women's sides.
The regional format has also meant that girls that haven't been involved in the age grade set-up have an opportunity to catch the attention of the national selectors.
So clearly in the last few years the WRU has been trying to drive forward the women's game in Wales but if we take a closer look perhaps things aren't quite as rosy.
The WRU website remains sporadic and unreliable at best when updating anything below the Premiership on the men's side of the game, but if you look at the women’s section the Cup competition hasn’t been updated since 2009!
But if Wales were to drop down to Tier 2, what would it mean for women involved in Wales' national sport?
This revelation would undoubtedly be a major backward step, not to mention turning our players' elation of securing a well-deserved World Cup place completely on its head. The Welsh women already give up their time not for money but for the love of their sport and the chance to represent their country at the highest level.
The London Olympics had been seen by many as a watershed moment for women both
in and outside of the sporting arena, with athletes such as Jessica Ennis and
Katherine Grainger starring on the competitive stage, while Clare Balding
captured the hearts of the nation with her very human approach to sports
reporting. Despite this encouraging change, however, what this situation has
shown is that clearly the same obstacles remain for many women in sport.
From my experience having been involved in many different facets
of rugby in Wales, there are still a lot of draconian views entrenched in the
cogs of the WRU system – such as the referee advisor who refused to assess my
performance as I was refereeing a women’s match describing it as not ‘proper
rugby’.
It is not only confined to the WRU; you only need to look as far
as BBC Wales' flagship rugby program Scrum V to see the under representation of
the women’s game and to be fair, the Welsh Under 20’s side, too. I’m not sure
about you but I’d rather see extended highlights of our country's national
teams at whatever level than watch Rick O’Shea prance around with the England
squad!
At the beginning of the week, I wrote an article in parts that
defended the work the WRU did to help bolster age grade and grassroots sport,
and if the WRU are supporting this new venture of a two tier women’s 6 Nations,
surely Chief Executive Roger Lewis is reneging on his promises to support grassroots
rugby.
It would not only disrespect the women who take unpaid leave
from work to represent their country, but also young girls playing at age grade
who aspire to pull on their national colours one day, all simply because it is
an inconvenience to the WRU budget.
That’s
why we need to get behind the Welsh women and make sure this travesty fails to
come to fruition! Who’s with me?
We are with you!! We cannot allow this to happen it is a disgrace.
ReplyDelete@WRUWomenSupporter follow us on ttwitter
The level of enthusiasm demonstrated here at Penallta by players & supporters alike for the newly formed Minerbirds cannot be allowed to be trivialised by the WRU. We have worked hard to form, develop & support our team and have many new players who have never picked up a rugby ball before. Are we wasting our time?? Seems like it....
ReplyDeleteIf they take the National 15s, they can't justify the Regional 15s, then goes club rugby.
ReplyDeleteIt will be the death of Women's rugby in Wales
Don't get me started! There is something fundamentally wrong with Welsh womens rugby at the moment. Things were meant to improve with the WWRU coming under the banner of the WRUif anything this move has made matters worse. There are too few staff trying to spread themselves too thinly. All eggs now seem to be focused on one area 7's. & everything else is kicked to touch. Whilst the 7's game is developing you cant forget what feeds the whole structure. Yhe 15's game. There is no under 18.. or U20 programme at national level. And the recent disbandment of the 15's regional programme will be regretted when girls turn their backs on rugby for honours in other sports. I may be naieve and that may be the aim...with no players to feed the structure the collapse of womens rugby will be academic. And they'll be happy to sit back &let it happen. This after all is a man's sport. This is just the start!
ReplyDelete